mrgl

The PvP ruleset locks you to one faction: decide before you roll

One Alliance character on PvP means you can never make a Horde one there. It is the most permanent decision in Forever, it is official, and it is the one most people will find out about afterwards.

PvPAccount-wide6 steps2 steps need a group

Last verified 10 November 2026

Levels
30–60
Where
Dustwallow Marsh
Group
15 players
More
Darkspear Islands: who's going, and every guide to it

Finish these first

Steps

0 of 6 done

0%

  1. 1

    One faction. For the whole ruleset. Forever.

    This is Blizzard's own wording, and it is worth reading slowly:

    "On the PvP ruleset, players can only create characters for one faction. Once you create an Alliance character on the PvP ruleset, you won't be able to create a Horde character there, and vice versa."

    Not one character. Not one slot. The ruleset. The first character you create on PvP decides which half of the game you can play there, and there is no published way back.

    Everything else on this site is a decision you can work around. This one you cannot. A friend who rolls the other faction on PvP is not someone you can meet halfway. You would both need to start again on Normal, or one of you starts again on PvP.

    So settle this before anyone rolls anything: which faction, with which people, on which ruleset. That conversation takes ten minutes now and is impossible later. The rulesets compared side by side shows what each one locks you into.

    ~5 min
    1 source
  2. 2

    Normal, Roleplaying and Hardcore do not do this

    "On Normal, Roleplaying, and Hardcore rulesets, you can create characters from both factions."

    Roleplay-PvP is the open question. Blizzard added it for launch on 22 October, and its faction rules do not mention it yet. Treat it as locked until Blizzard says otherwise.

    That is the whole difference, and it cuts both ways:

    • If you want to play both sides, or keep your options open, PvP is the one ruleset that forecloses it.
    • If you want the faction war to mean something, that foreclosure is the feature. Nobody on your server is quietly playing the other side.

    Blizzard describes the ruleset as being for "players who want every trip into contested territory to carry more danger, excitement, and open-world conflict." The faction lock is what makes that true rather than decorative.

    Note it is per ruleset, not per account. Locking Alliance on PvP does not stop you rolling Horde on Normal. The lock lives on the PvP mega-server, not on you.

    ~3 min
    2 sources
  3. 3

    Why the lock exists, and what it tells you about population

    There are no realms in Forever: one mega-server per ruleset, per region. That removes the old escape hatch: when a server's factions went lopsided, people transferred. Here there is nowhere to transfer to.

    Blizzard has said what it plans to do instead:

    "For the PvP ruleset, faction balance remains an important consideration, and World of Warcraft: Forever will include systems intended to help keep Horde and Alliance populations closer together similar to the approach introduced in Season of Discovery, where new character creation could be temporarily limited for a faction when additional balance support was needed."

    Now it is happening (10 November). Blizzard says "it will become increasingly difficult to create characters on the more populous faction in each region", which is "currently Horde on North American PvP rulesets or Alliance in EU Roleplay-PvP." The aim is to "bring things as close to a 50/50 faction balance as possible", judged on the balance over time "rather than what may feel like snapshots of points in time." Blizzard gives no start date and does not say how hard "difficult" gets.

    If you are rolling Horde on North American PvP, or Alliance on EU Roleplay-PvP, make your character now, and make the alts you plan to make. Rolling with your group in one go is safer than one at a time.

    Practical read: the minority faction on a PvP mega-server has a very different game from the majority one, and the majority side is now the one that gets harder to roll. If that matters to you, that is an argument for rolling with a group rather than alone, which is the point of the next step.

    ~4 min
    4 sources
  4. 4

    Horde or Alliance? What is actually known

    Blizzard has given one number: "even the most extreme case in a region is currently at roughly a 55/45 split" (10 November), without saying which region or which side is 55. Horde leads on North American PvP and Alliance on EU Roleplay-PvP. The biggest known number comes from the press: Olympus, Asmongold's Alliance guild, reportedly has "nearly 74,000 members on Forever's PvP server", which GameSpot calls "the size of six or more entire WoW Classic servers and growing". The article does not say which region, and a guild's member count is not the same as people online.

    What that means for your choice, if it holds at launch:

    • Alliance on PvP will very likely be the bigger side where Olympus plays. That makes it the side Blizzard's balance system is most likely to close to new characters at times (see the step above). If you are going Alliance, make your character during name reservation, October 27 to November 3, rather than on launch night.
    • Horde on PvP will very likely be the smaller side there. Nobody can transfer away from that, because there is only one PvP mega-server per region.
    • Normal, Roleplaying and Hardcore do not lock your faction, so none of this is permanent there.

    Our own numbers: the population page shows the Horde and Alliance split among characters on mrgl, per region and ruleset, once enough people have added one. It counts mrgl's players, not the whole game.

    The deciding question is still the one in the last step: which side are the people you will play with on? A smaller side with your friends beats a bigger side without them.

    ~5 min
    6 sources
  5. 5

    Darkspear Islands: the new 15v15, and what it is made of

    The new battleground is described by Blizzard like this:

    "For PvP, the Darkspear Islands will introduce a 15 vs 15 Battleground off the coast of Kalimdor, combining strategic control points with Arathi Basin-style flag captures and defense."

    Three things follow from that sentence, and they are the useful part:

    • 15 a side is not a number vanilla had. It is bigger than a 10-man and smaller than a 40-man, which means a premade is fifteen people who all turn up, a guild-sized commitment, not a group-sized one.
    • Control points plus flag captures means it rewards a team that has decided who goes where before the gates open. Pick-up groups lose these on coordination long before they lose them on gear.
    • Off the coast of Kalimdor (Blizzard later said Dustwallow Marsh) is a location, not a mechanic, but it is the one detail that tells you this is new content rather than a returning map.

    Now from Blizzard (7 October): levels 30 to 60, first team to 2000 points wins, and each side has its own reputation, with a tabard at Exalted. Honor is a currency that buys a blue and an epic set of PvP gear, and ranks have a weekly cap. Icy Veins adds four brackets (30–39, 40–49, 50–59 and 60) and says battleground queues mix the rulesets. The details, with their sources, are in the Darkspear Islands guide.

    Still not published: whether it is available at launch or later. We have found nothing either way and are not going to guess.

    ~10 minNeeds a group
    8 sources
  6. 6

    Find the people before you make the choice you cannot unmake

    Every other checklist here tells you to find a group for a thing you are doing. This one is different: the group has to exist before the decision, because the decision is permanent and it has to match theirs.

    Fifteen people is also the shape of the new battleground, which is not a coincidence you should waste. A guild that lands on PvP with one faction agreed is a guild that can field a Darkspear Islands premade. Fifteen individuals who each chose separately are, quite often, fifteen people split across two factions and several rulesets.

    Post it, or find one: the board is scoped by region and ruleset and faction precisely because those three together are what determines whether two people can actually play together. For this decision, that scoping is not a filter. It is the whole question.

    ~10 minNeeds a group
    1 source

Sources